Verifying Validity, Accuracy and Bias



DeepSeek




PROMPT:




Enhance and improve the following prompt:




Verify the Validity, Accuracy and Bias of the following:




RESPONSE:




Here's an enhanced and improved version of your prompt, designed to be more specific, actionable, and comprehensive while guiding the user to provide necessary context:




---




Enhanced Prompt:

"Critically evaluate the following content for validity, accuracy, and potential bias. Provide a structured analysis addressing these key areas:




1. Source Evaluation:

Who is the author/organization? What are their credentials, affiliations, or potential agendas?

Is the source reputable? (e.g., peer-reviewed journal, established news outlet, known propaganda site)

2. Evidence & Support:

Are claims backed by verifiable evidence (data, citations, primary sources)?

Is the evidence recent, relevant, and methodologically sound?

Are counter-arguments or limitations acknowledged?

3. Objectivity & Bias Indicators:

Identify loaded language, emotional appeals, or framing that favors one perspective.

Are multiple viewpoints presented fairly, or is there oversimplification/strawmanning?

Does the tone feel neutral or persuasive? Is there potential for omission of key facts?

4. Logical Consistency:

Do the conclusions logically follow from the evidence presented?

Are there logical fallacies (e.g., ad hominem, false dilemma, correlation/causation errors)?

5. Context & Corroboration:

How does this information align with established knowledge or consensus on the topic?

Can key claims be corroborated by independent, reliable sources?




Please provide the specific content (text, article excerpt, claim, image description, or URL) you want evaluated.




Output Preference (Optional but Recommended):

Provide a summary rating (e.g., High/Medium/Low) for Validity, Accuracy, and Bias.

List specific strengths and weaknesses found.

Highlight the most significant potential red flags."




---




Key Improvements & Why:




1. Specificity: Breaks down "Validity, Accuracy, and Bias" into concrete, actionable sub-questions (Source, Evidence, Bias Indicators, Logic, Context). This guides the evaluator how to assess each dimension.

2. Action-Oriented: Uses verbs like "Evaluate," "Identify," "Assess," "Corroborate" to drive a thorough analysis.

3. Context Requirement: Explicitly asks the user to provide the content to be evaluated. The original prompt lacked this crucial element.

4. Bias Nuance: Moves beyond just "bias" to identify indicators (language, framing, omission, perspective fairness) and acknowledges potential agendas.

5. Added Critical Dimensions:

Source Evaluation: Essential foundation for assessing credibility.

Logical Consistency: Checks for reasoning errors, strengthening validity assessment.

Context & Corroboration: Places the information within the broader landscape of knowledge and checks against other sources.

6. Structured Output (Optional): Offers suggestions for how the results could be presented (ratings, strengths/weaknesses, red flags), making the output more usable for the requester.

7. Clarity: Uses clearer language and avoids ambiguity.




When to Use This Enhanced Prompt




Evaluating news articles, opinion pieces, or social media claims.

Assessing research summaries, reports, or presentations.

Fact-checking specific statements or data.

Analyzing marketing materials or political communications.

Developing critical thinking skills about information consumption.




By using this enhanced prompt, you significantly increase the likelihood of receiving a detailed, structured, and genuinely useful critical analysis of the information in question. Remember to always include the specific content you want evaluated!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Minute Clinic Error

You.com   PROMPT:  Improve the following prompt: Analyze the attached medical statement. List instructions for confirming how and why Medicare B-MO would deny payment.  RESPONSE:  Role: Act as an experienced medical billing specialist with expertise in Medicare Part B Managed Organization (B-MO) claims processing. Task: Analyze the attached medical statement and provide a detailed assessment of potential denial factors for Medicare B-MO payment. Please provide the following analysis: 1. Coverage Verification - Confirm if the services listed fall under Medicare Part B covered services - Verify if the services are classified as medically necessary or preventive - Check if any services are explicitly excluded from Medicare B-MO coverage 2. Provider Information Analysis - Verify provider credentials and Medicare participation status - Confirm if the provider type is authorized to perform the billed services - Check for any provider-specific restrictions or limitations 3....
Read more

Schengen Area Visa Rules (Applies to Most of Europe, Including Spain)

Qwen PROMPT: I had a conversation with wife about the possibility of traveling to Spain for the upcoming eclipse. We discussed the idea of staying for as long as our visa permits. As a retired American couple, how long are we allowed to stay in Europe on a visa? We've decided to make the most of our time there and stay for the maximum duration allowed. RESPONSE: That sounds like a wonderful plan — combining the awe of a total solar eclipse with a memorable trip to Spain and possibly other parts of Europe! As American retirees planning to travel to Europe, here’s what you need to know about visa rules for U.S. citizens: 🇪🇺 Schengen Area Visa Rules (Applies to Most of Europe, Including Spain) As U.S. citizens, you do not need a visa for short-term tourism stays in the Schengen Area for up to 90 days in any 180-day period. This applies to countries like: - Spain - France - Germany - Italy - Netherlands - And most Western, Central, and Southern European countries This is part of th...
Read more

Culinary Challenge Leftover Duck Meat - Cuban-Asian Fusion Sofrito Potato Chowder

Image
CHATGOT   PROMPT:   Enhance and improve the following prompt: Provide three recipes that include the following ingredients: Soy sauce Sesame oil Hoisin sauce Ginger paste onion Potato Sweet potatoes Radishes Dorito Sofrito Noodles Leftover Duck meat RESPONSE: Sure! Here’s an enhanced prompt to make it more engaging and clear: --- Creative Culinary Challenge: Let's put your cooking skills to the test! I’d love for you to provide three delicious and unique recipes that creatively incorporate the following key ingredients: - Soy sauce - Sesame oil - Hoisin sauce - Ginger paste - Onion - Potato - Sweet potatoes - Radishes - Doritos (for a fun twist!) - Sofrito - Noodles - Leftover duck meat Feel free to get innovative with flavors and textures! Share detailed instructions, cooking times, and any special tips to elevate each dish. Happy cooking!  ---  This version encourages creativity and provides a more structured approach to the task.   Perplexity PROMPT: Provide ...
Read more